10 Things to Remember When Introducing a New Cat to Your Other Cats

10 Things to Remember When Introducing a New Cat to Your Other Cats

From Dr Tanya · Founder & Veterinarian

10 Things to Remember When Introducing a New Cat to Your Other Cats


A Vet's guide to calmer cat introductions in a multi-cat home

Bringing home a new cat or kitten is such an exciting moment. But if you already have cats at home, it can also feel a little overwhelming.

Will your resident cat accept the new cat? Will there be hissing? Will your new kitten hide? How do you stop stress, fighting or litter tray issues in a multi-cat household?

As a Sydney Veterinarian, lifelong cat parent and founder of Best Fur Forward, this is one of the most important pieces of cat care advice I can give.

And I have experienced this recently myself when I introduced my new kitten Ky into our home, where Kenji, my 5 year old cat, had very much been the Prince of the household.

Introducing cats should never be rushed.

Cats feel safest when their world smells familiar. Their scent map helps them understand what belongs, where they are safe, and when something new has entered their space.

So when you are introducing a new cat to your existing cat, the goal is not to make them instant best friends.

The goal is to help both cats feel safe, calm and confident in the same home.

Here are 10 things to remember when introducing a new cat or kitten to the cats already living in your household.

Kenji and Ky resting together on a cosy blanket

Kenji and Ky — proof that patience pays off

01

Your new cat needs a safe room first

Before your new cat comes home, set up a separate room just for them. This is their safe space.

It might be a spare bedroom, study, laundry or bathroom. The room should be quiet, secure and comfortable, with everything your new cat or kitten needs.

Set up:

  • A litter tray
  • Food and water bowls placed away from the litter tray
  • A cosy bed
  • Hiding places
  • A scratching post or mat
  • Toys
  • A perch or elevated resting spot
  • A soft blanket or towel that can hold their scent

This room is not a punishment. It is your new cat's first safe little world inside your home.

For new cat owners, this step is especially important. Your new cat needs time to understand the smells, sounds and routines of your home before they are expected to meet another cat.

02

Let your new cat settle before any introductions begin

When your new cat arrives home, take them straight to their safe room in a covered carrier. Do not let your cats see each other yet.

Open the carrier door and let your new cat come out in their own time.

Some cats will walk out quickly. Some cats will hide. Some cats may not eat much at first. Some cats may only explore when the house is quiet. This can all be normal in the first few days.

Your first goal is not introduction. Your first goal is to make them feel safe.

It can take your new cat or kitten at least 3 days to decompress and start to understand their new environment. Some cats will need longer, especially if they are shy, overwhelmed, recently rehomed or coming from a rescue, shelter or busy household.

Do not rush them out of their safe room. Let them stay there until they are showing signs of confidence, curiosity and interest in what is happening outside the door.

Your new cat's safe room may need to remain their main space for several days and, for some cats, up to 2 weeks. Even once they start exploring, keep this room available as their retreat space.

For the first week, avoid letting your new cat freely roam the whole house. Give them time to adjust, build confidence and slowly show you their personality.

Close bedroom doors for at least the first 2 weeks, and only allow access to bedrooms under supervision. Bedrooms carry very strong human scent, especially on beds, rugs, clothing, shoes and soft furnishings.

A new cat who is overwhelmed or trying to make an unfamiliar space feel familiar may toilet on these items. Once a cat has urinated on a bed, rug or piece of clothing, they can be drawn back to that same area again. In some cases, this can become a toileting habit that is very difficult to reverse.

So go slowly. Keep their world small at first. Let them build confidence one safe space at a time. And always make sure they know exactly where their litter tray is and how to get back to it.

03

Your resident cat needs reassurance too

Your existing cat did not choose to have a new cat move into their home. From their point of view, their familiar world has changed.

So while your new cat is settling in, make sure your resident cat still feels loved, secure and important.

  • Keep their routine as normal as possible
  • Feed them at the usual time
  • Keep their favourite resting places available
  • Play with them and spend time with them
  • Give them attention without forcing them near the new cat
  • Do not remove them from their favourite places
  • Do not push them off your lap because the new kitten has arrived
  • Do not change everything they know all at once

This helps your resident cat feel that they have not been replaced. A calmer resident cat will usually cope much better with the introduction process.

If you know your cat is likely to struggle with change, it may also be worth speaking with your Vet before your new cat arrives. There are calming supplements, diets and pheromone products that may help support some cats during stressful periods.

Some Veterinary options that may be discussed include products such as Zylkene, Protexin SereniCare, Royal Canin Calm and Feliway. Always speak with your own Vet about what is suitable for your individual cat.

04

Scent comes before sight

Cats feel safest when their world smells familiar. Their scent map helps them understand what belongs, where they are safe, and when something new has entered their space.

When my kitten Ky first arrived home, Kenji did not even need to see him to know something had changed. For the first few days, Kenji would hiss at us when we came near him because we smelled like the new kitten.

Not because he was being naughty. Not because he was a bad cat. And not because the introduction had failed. He was simply responding to a completely new scent in his familiar home.

Before cats meet face to face, they need time to safely learn each other's smell without the pressure of direct contact.

Start by swapping soft items between them. Place a blanket, towel or bedding item from your new cat's room into your resident cat's area. Then place something that smells like your resident cat into your new cat's safe room.

You can also gently rub a soft cloth around one cat's cheeks and chin, then place that cloth in the other cat's space.

Keep this positive. Use treats, gentle praise or play nearby so each cat starts to associate the other cat's scent with something calm and safe.

05

Let them explore each other's spaces before they meet

Once both cats seem calm with each other's scent, you can begin gentle space swapping.

This means your new cat gets to explore part of your home while your resident cat is safely in another room. Then your resident cat can explore the new cat's room while your new cat is somewhere else.

They are learning about each other without the pressure of direct contact. Cats gather so much information through scent. They can smell where the other cat has slept, scratched, eaten and moved through the home.

Keep these sessions short at first. Then return your new cat to their safe room.

Allow space swapping only under supervision and only when each cat is showing interest and confidence. If either cat seems overwhelmed, go back a step. Slow progress is still progress.

Kenji and Ky sleeping together peacefully Kenji and Ky cuddling close up
06

Keep routines steady before expecting shared space

When you are introducing a new cat, it can be tempting to focus all your attention on the new arrival. But your resident cat needs reassurance too.

During the early stages, keep your resident cat's routine as normal and predictable as possible. Feed them where they are used to eating. Keep their litter tray where they expect it to be. Keep their resting spaces available.

Later in the introduction process, once your cats are more confident and can spend calm, supervised time in the same room, you can start using mealtimes more intentionally.

At that stage, you may start feeding them in the same common area, but on opposite sides of the room. Do not place them too close together at first. Start with plenty of distance, and only move them closer over days or weeks if both cats are relaxed.

Calm comes first. Closeness comes later.
07

Visual introductions should be short and protected

When both cats are relaxed with scent swapping and space swapping, you can begin short visual introductions. The time to reach this stage could be days or weeks. Take it at their pace.

Use a barrier. This may be a baby gate, screen door, glass door, mesh barrier or a slightly opened door with a secure divider. The cats should be able to see each other, but not touch each other.

Keep the first session very short. A few seconds to a few minutes may be enough. Offer treats, food or play on both sides of the barrier.

End the session while things are still calm.

If you notice staring, tail flicking, growling, hissing, crouching, chasing behaviour or one cat trying to hide, calmly end the session and go back a step. This is not failure. This is listening to your cats.

08

The first time in the same room should be supervised

Once both cats are calm seeing each other through a barrier, you can try short supervised time in the same room, but make sure this is a neutral space, not the new cat's safe space.

Set them up for success:

  • Choose a larger room where both cats have space to move away
  • Have treats ready
  • Have toys ready
  • Have escape routes available, especially close to the new cat's safe space
  • Have hiding spaces available
  • Have something nearby that can safely block their view if needed

Keep each cat engaged separately. One person can play with one cat while another person rewards or plays with the other cat. Keep the session short and positive.

The goal is not friendship on day one. The goal is calm, safe shared space.

Gradually increase the time they spend together, but only if both cats are coping well. This may take weeks. It may take months. Do not rush it.

09

Every cat needs their own resources

In a multi-cat household, cats should not have to compete for the basics. Competition can create stress, even if it is subtle.

Each cat should have access to:

  • Separate food stations
  • Separate water stations
  • Separate resting areas
  • Separate hiding places
  • Separate scratching areas
  • Multiple litter trays

For litter trays, the general rule is: one litter tray per cat, plus one extra. So if you have 2 cats, aim for 3 litter trays.

Litter tray stress can become a real issue in multi-cat homes. This can lead to unwanted behaviours such as urinating in abnormal places, aggressive behaviour around the litter tray, stalking, spraying and even stress-induced cystitis.

A clean, low dust, odour control cat litter can make everyday cat care easier, especially when more than one cat is sharing the same home.

This is one of the reasons I created MATCHA. MATCHA™ was developed for real cat homes, including multi-cat homes, where odour, dust, tracking and tray stress can become everyday frustrations. It has a small pellet size that is gentle for sensitive paws, especially for kittens. It clumps firmly, neutralises odours naturally and helps keep the tray easier to maintain.

10

Slow progress is still progress

Some cats adjust quickly. Others take weeks or even months. Some cats never become best friends and simply live separate lives while tolerating each other.

That does not mean you have failed. It means you are respecting the cats in front of you.

Not all cats become cuddly companions who share beds and groom each other. Some become best friends. Some peacefully share a home. Some prefer their own space and simply tolerate each other. That can still be a successful outcome.

The goal is not always friendship. The goal is safety, confidence and a calm home where every cat has their needs met.

Only leave your cats together unsupervised when you are genuinely confident they can tolerate each other calmly. Until then, keep sessions short, positive and supervised.

Signs your cats may need more time

Cat stress is not always obvious. It is not always a big fight. Sometimes cat behaviour changes are subtle.

Watch for these signs

  • Staring
  • Blocking access to food, water, doorways or litter trays
  • Hiding more than usual
  • Stalking or ambushing the other cat
  • Eating less
  • Changes in litter tray habits
  • Hissing or growling
  • Swatting or chasing
  • Overgrooming
  • Urine spraying
  • One cat seeming unable to relax

If you see these signs, slow down. Go back a step. Give both cats more space, more resources and more time.

If there is serious fighting, injury, ongoing toileting changes, urine spraying, not eating or persistent stress, please speak with your Vet or a qualified Veterinary behaviour professional.

What not to do when introducing cats

  • Do not put cats together and expect them to work it out
  • Do not punish hissing or growling
  • Do not hold one cat up to another cat's face
  • Do not force them to sniff each other
  • Do not let them fight it out
  • Do not rush because you feel guilty keeping the new cat in one room
  • Do not assume that hissing means the introduction has failed
Hissing is communication. It often means: "I need more space." Listen to it.

My Vet Advice

When introducing a new cat or kitten to your household, slow is kind.

Cats need time to feel safe. They need scent before sight. They need choice before contact. They need separate resources. They need calm humans who do not panic when things take longer than expected.

And your resident cat needs to feel that they have not been replaced.

So keep giving them love. Keep their routine steady. Feed them first if that is what they are used to. Let them keep their favourite places.

Let your new cat settle. Move one step at a time.

A calm introduction now can make all the difference to the long-term peace of your home.

Because cat care is not just about food, toys and cat litter. It is about understanding how cats feel safe in the world. And when we understand that, we can create homes where cats can truly settle, relax and live their best life.

A note on introducing your new cat to a dog or other animals

If you are introducing your new cat to a dog or other animals in the household, the same slow, supervised approach applies.

Do not assume they will be okay together just because your dog is friendly, or because your new cat has lived with dogs before.

All early interactions should be under close supervision until you feel completely confident that they can be together safely.

Your new cat must always have multiple safe ways to get away:

  • Hiding places
  • Elevated areas and cat trees
  • Shelves
  • Rooms they can retreat to
  • Baby gates or barriers where the cat can pass through but the dog cannot

The cat should never feel trapped. Do not allow your dog to chase your cat. Even if the dog is just playing, your cat may not experience it that way.

Keep your dog calm, controlled and rewarded for relaxed behaviour around the cat. Use leads, barriers and distance where needed.

Supervision first. Safety always. Friendship can come later.

A note on litter trays in multi-cat homes

If you are introducing a new cat, this is also the perfect time to review your litter tray setup.

Cats are very sensitive to smell, texture, cleanliness and access. In a multi-cat household, a litter tray that smells, tracks through the home, creates dust or is difficult to keep clean can add extra stress to an already sensitive introduction period.

Conventional Clay Litter

What's inside

  • Strip-mined clay
  • Crystalline silica dust
  • Sodium bentonite
  • Artificial fragrances
  • Landfill at end of life

MATCHA by BFF

What's inside

  • Soybean fibre (food-grade)
  • Real green tea fibre
  • Natural starch binder
  • Zero synthetic additives
  • Home compostable

MATCHA™ is Australia's first Vet-developed plant-based clumping cat litter, created for cats and the people they own. It is designed for:

  • Powerful natural odour control
  • Fast, firm clumping
  • Low dust comfort
  • Low tracking
  • Easy daily scooping
  • Cleaner litter trays
  • A fresher, calmer home
  • Longer lasting litter

Because when your cat's litter tray is easier to keep clean, everyday cat care feels calmer too.

Kenji and Ky relaxing together at home

A calm introduction now can make all the difference

A Cleaner Standard for Cat Litter

No smell. No mess. No stress.

Small change. Big impact. One tray at a time.

Try MATCHA →